Site icon Erika Vieira

How a Beauty Creator Turned YouTube Into a $355 Million Brand

Susan Yara

How a Beauty Creator Turned YouTube Into a $355 Million Brand

I’ll be honest—I love a juicy creator story. Especially the ones that make you pause and think: Wait… how did she pull that off?

Susan Yara built a skincare brand during lockdown. Got hit with the biggest FTC investigation against a content creator… ever. And still sold that brand—Naturium—for $355 million to ELF Beauty.

That’s not luck. That’s strategy.

Most people know her name. But almost no one understands the real story behind that exit—or the creator advantages that made it possible. As a YouTube strategist for nearly a decade, I study this stuff. Not to gossip, but to decode what actually drives creator success and long-term wealth.

So let’s break down how Susan went from beauty editor to multimillion-dollar founder—and what you, as a creator, can apply to your own business (even if you’re just starting with 1,000 subscribers).

She Didn’t Start With Millions of Followers

Susan wasn’t a celebrity or viral sensation. She was a trained journalist, a pageant queen, and a skincare nerd with 11 years of behind-the-scenes beauty experience. When investors told her she was “too old” to be on YouTube at 30, she launched her own channel anyway.

She treated it like a business from day one—bringing on experts, doing deep ingredient dives, and turning every video into market research. Her audience didn’t just watch—they trusted her.

She Used Her YouTube Channel as a Data Goldmine

While most creators chase views, Susan paid attention to the comments, click-throughs, and conversions. She used that data to understand what her audience actually wanted—and when she launched Naturium, it wasn’t a shot in the dark. It was a product they were already asking for.

This is the creator advantage too many overlook: you have access to more real-time customer insights than most startups ever will.

She Didn’t Try to Do It All Alone

Here’s where Susan really stood out: she partnered with an operations expert and stayed focused on content and marketing—what she did best. That’s how Naturium scaled during lockdown and landed retail partnerships with Target and Ulta.

Meanwhile, other creators who insisted on total control (like the Ace Family or Jaclyn Hill) saw their brands crash and burn. Execution matters more than hype.

Yes, She Made a Huge Mistake—And Still Rebounded

Let’s talk about the FTC scandal. Susan promoted Naturium without disclosing she co-founded it. That’s illegal—and the internet let her know it. The backlash was intense. The investigation lasted two years. And it could’ve ended everything.

But here’s what’s wild: ELF bought Naturium anyway. Because the fundamentals were that strong. Profitable, growing, data-backed, and deeply trusted by its target customer.

That’s the kind of business acquirers want—not just something “influencer cute.”

The Takeaway? You’re Not “Just” a Creator

You’re sitting on leverage most people don’t even see.

If you’re intentional, strategic, and willing to treat content like a business, you can build something bigger than brand deals or AdSense. Susan did it. And her playbook is one we can all learn from.

So let me ask you:

Would you ever launch your own product or brand?

What’s holding you back?

Keep creating. Keep building. And never underestimate what’s possible with a small channel and a smart strategy.

Resources

YOUTUBE OPTIMIZATION PLUG-IN I RECOMMEND

TubeBuddy [Use the code ErikasBuddy to get 20% off]

MY FAVORITE BUSINESS TOOLS

Course Creation: Looking to create a course? Kajabi is the BEST platform hands down. I use this for my course after extensive research on all the other platforms.

Live Calls and Interviews: I use Ecamm for my podcast interviews, both audio and for YouTube that you see here on YouTube. It makes it super easy to share my screen and create the split-screen with my guest. I’m not super techie and this software is really easy to use!

Webinars and Live calls: I use Zoom.us for my group coaching calls in my private membership group for female YouTube creators. It’s also the software I use to record my Road to 100k YouTube Subscribers Masterclass!

THE BEST YOUTUBE/PODCASTING EQUIPMENT

After interviewing HUNDREDS of successful YouTube creators, and being asked all the time what equipment I recommend for YouTubers, I created a list! Click here to see all my recommended equipment for YouTubers!

Podcast Music Credit: Boop by x50 @x50music
Music provided by Free Music for Vlogs youtu.be/o52xQkQWzyU

*Erika Vieira is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to www.amazon.com.
**Disclaimers: all opinions are my own, sponsors are acknowledged. Links in the description are typically affiliate links that let you help support the podcast at no extra cost.SaveSave

Susan Yara

Author: Erika Vieira

Marketing and sales expert Erika Vieira is the host and producer of the #1 influencer strategy podcast, The YouTube Power Hour. The podcast, with over 100 episodes and hundreds of thousands of downloads is dedicated to content creators who are looking to start, improve and grow their unique influence online. Erika works with influencers on personal branding, content improvement and defining a niche via customized strategy sessions, channel critiques and business support. She also loves makeup, beauty and her family and believes anyone who has the drive and passion can find success online. Feel free to send her a message here.

Exit mobile version