Instagram vs. YouTube: Why Long-Form Video Is Still the Best Investment for Creators
Instagram is making a play for long-form video, and it’s a pretty interesting development for anyone building a business as a content creator.
The platform has been exploring videos up to 90 minutes long, with reports of substantial financial incentives being offered to select creators willing to bring their existing YouTube content over to Instagram.
And I have to say, I get it.
After nearly a decade of helping women grow and monetize their YouTube channels, I’ve seen firsthand how valuable long-form video can be. It’s one of the most powerful ways to build an audience that genuinely trusts you, and that trust can translate into serious revenue.
But does Instagram embracing long-form video mean creators should start prioritizing it over YouTube?
Not so fast.
Why Instagram Wants Long-Form Video Creators
Social media platforms need creators. Without creators, there’s no content. Without content, there are no viewers. And without viewers, there’s no advertising revenue.
So when a platform introduces a new content format, it needs people to start creating for it.
Think about a brand-new shopping mall. If there aren’t any stores, nobody has a reason to visit. But if the mall offers attractive deals to a few major retailers, other stores eventually follow, and the shoppers come with them.
That’s essentially how I see Instagram’s push into long-form content.
Rather than asking creators to reinvent their entire production process, Instagram has reportedly encouraged some established creators to bring over the videos they’re already producing for YouTube.
It’s a smart strategy. Instagram knows that people are already watching short clips on Reels and then leaving the platform to watch the full video somewhere else.
Why wouldn’t Instagram want to keep those viewers?
But there’s an important distinction between Instagram experimenting with long-form video and Instagram having an established monetization ecosystem for it.
And that’s where YouTube has a significant advantage.
Long-Form Video Builds Something Short-Form Can’t Replicate
One of the biggest reasons I believe in long-form content is the relationship it creates between a creator and her audience.
I like to explain it this way: Short-form content is like waving at someone across a crowded room. Long-form YouTube is the dinner date.
When someone watches a 20- or 30-minute video, they’re spending meaningful time with you. They’re hearing how you think, learning from your experience, and developing a sense of whether they trust you.
That relationship becomes even more valuable when you’re selling products, services, coaching programs, or anything that requires a significant financial investment.
I experienced this in my own business when I hired a marketing expert to help with my sales funnels. He told me he wouldn’t work with someone who didn’t have a YouTube channel.
His reasoning was simple. Every email in the funnel could direct people back to one of my long-form videos. By the time someone received an offer, they had already spent hours learning from me.
The videos were doing the trust-building before the sale ever happened.
Why YouTube Subscribers Can Be More Valuable Than Instagram Followers
I’ve seen the financial impact of this with my own clients.
Katie Ferraro, who teaches baby-led weaning, had already built a substantial audience on Instagram and established herself in the podcasting world when she decided to launch her YouTube channel.
She had more than 500,000 Instagram followers, but when her YouTube channel reached around 20,000 subscribers, she told me those YouTube subscribers were generating more revenue than her Instagram and podcast combined.
Think about that for a second.
Twenty thousand YouTube subscribers were producing more income than an Instagram audience of over half a million.
I’ve seen something similar with Annette and Sarah from Thanks for Visiting, who teach people how to build successful short-term rental businesses. Their YouTube channel became responsible for 76% of their leads.
These examples illustrate something I wish more creators understood: The number of followers you have isn’t nearly as important as the relationship you have with them and what those viewers actually do.
You don’t necessarily need the biggest audience. You need the right audience spending meaningful time with your content.
YouTube Videos Have a Much Longer Shelf Life
Here’s another reason I continue to prioritize YouTube: Your content can keep working for you long after you publish it.
On Instagram, so much of the content experience revolves around what’s happening right now. You post something, it gets attention, and then you’re creating something else to stay visible.
YouTube works differently.
A video you upload today can continue attracting viewers through search, recommendations, and related videos months or years later.
I have clients who still make money from videos they published more than a decade ago. Sometimes those older videos even experience a resurgence because a particular topic becomes relevant again.
One former YouTube employee I interviewed described these older videos as potential cash cows. A relatively small collection of videos can sometimes account for a substantial portion of a channel’s views and revenue over time.
That’s what makes YouTube so powerful as a business asset.
You’re not just creating content for today’s audience. You’re building a library that future viewers can discover.
AI Search Is Creating Another Opportunity for YouTube Creators
There’s another development making YouTube particularly interesting for business owners and experts: AI search.
People aren’t exclusively turning to traditional search engines for answers anymore. They’re asking tools like ChatGPT and Gemini for recommendations, explanations, and solutions.
And YouTube content can become part of the information those systems use.
In a conversation with a former YouTube employee, we discussed how AI systems can process YouTube transcripts to understand what creators are teaching and discussing in their videos.
That means the information you share in a YouTube video has the potential to be discovered beyond YouTube itself.
If you’re a fitness expert, business consultant, financial educator, or someone with specialized knowledge, your videos can become part of the broader online conversation around your expertise.
Of course, appearing in AI-generated answers isn’t guaranteed. But it’s another reason I encourage business owners to create substantial, helpful content that clearly demonstrates what they know.
YouTube isn’t simply a place to upload videos. It’s a searchable library of your expertise.
YouTube Has Already Become a Major TV Platform
Something else I’ve been paying close attention to is how many people are watching YouTube on their televisions.
We’re no longer talking about a platform that people only watch on their phones or laptops.
YouTube has become a major part of the living-room viewing experience, and some of the creators I work with receive a substantial percentage of their views from connected TVs.
I’ve seen channels where 60%, 70%, or even 80% of views come from television screens.
That changes how we should think about YouTube content.
Your videos aren’t necessarily competing with another social media post. They’re competing for the same attention people give to television shows, documentaries, and streaming entertainment.
For creators who produce compelling long-form content, that’s a tremendous opportunity.
Instagram may be exploring ways to expand its own long-form and television experience, but YouTube has spent years developing its position in this space.
YouTube Already Has an Established Monetization System
Let’s talk about money, because this is another major difference between the platforms.
YouTube has an established Partner Program that allows eligible creators to earn advertising revenue from their videos. For standard long-form watch-page ads, creators receive a 55% revenue share.
And that’s only one way to monetize.
Creators can also generate income through affiliate marketing, brand partnerships, memberships, and their own products or services.
Instagram offers monetization opportunities too, including brand partnerships and other creator programs. But the financial incentives reportedly offered to select long-form creators shouldn’t be confused with a broadly available revenue-sharing program for everyone uploading longer videos.
When I’m helping someone build a YouTube business, I want them thinking beyond a temporary platform incentive.
I want them building something that has multiple ways to generate income and continues creating value over time.
Should You Repurpose Your YouTube Videos for Instagram?
So, with all of that said, should you start uploading your long-form YouTube videos to Instagram if the opportunity is available?
I don’t see why you shouldn’t experiment.
If you’ve already done the work of researching, planning, filming, and editing a long-form video, it may make sense to distribute that content on another platform where your audience spends time.
But I wouldn’t automatically shift your entire content strategy away from YouTube.
I like to think about content as a pyramid, with YouTube at the top.
You create one strong, valuable long-form video, and then you can use that video to produce shorter clips, Reels, TikToks, social posts, podcast content, and other promotional material.
That allows you to get more value from the work you’ve already done without constantly creating everything from scratch.
And importantly, your original YouTube video remains part of a growing content library that can continue attracting viewers and generating revenue.
Long-Form Content Is the Long Game
I’m excited to see more platforms recognizing the value of long-form video. If anything, I think Instagram’s interest reinforces something I’ve been teaching women creators for years.
Spending meaningful time with your audience matters.
It’s how you build trust, demonstrate expertise, and create the kind of relationship that can eventually turn viewers into customers, clients, and loyal fans.
But not all platforms offer the same opportunities for discovery, monetization, or long-term content performance.
For creators who want to build a sustainable business, I still believe YouTube deserves to be the foundation of their content strategy.
Experiment with other platforms. Repurpose your videos. Take advantage of new opportunities when they make sense.
Just don’t lose sight of the bigger picture.
Long-form, long game, ladies.
FREE RESOURCES
- Register for my FREE Masterclass
YOUTUBE COURSES AND COACHING
- YOUTUBE BOOTCAMP FOR WOMEN: Are you looking for support, coaching, community and proven systems that will help you achieve your YouTube goals? Join a unique, comprehensive YouTube growth bootcamp that will help you 10x your growth on YouTube and bring you the financial and creative freedom you want. Add your name to the YouTube Bootcamp waitlist so you are notified when space becomes available!
- 1:1 YOUTUBE COACHING: Are you wanting to go full time on YouTube within 3 months or are already full time and are wanting to invest in 1:1 coaching for your YouTube channel for rapid growth? Click here to apply!
- STRATEGIC CHANNEL MANAGEMENT: Are you a business looking for strategic channel management? Please email my team at support@erikavieira.net with Strategic Channel Management in the subject.
TRUSTED YOUTUBE TOOLS
- Poppy AI: my new favorite AI tool for YouTube creators! Click here to get Poppy and use code ErikaV for $25 off plus theres a 30 day money back guarantee!
- TubeBuddy: Click here to get TubeBuddy and use the code ErikasBuddy to get 20% off
- Kajabi: All-in-one course creation platform I use and LOVE! Click here to get Kajabi.
RECOMMENDED YOUTUBE/PODCASTING EQUIPMENT:
- Click here for my Amazon storefront to see my favorite products for YouTube creators
*Links include affiliate links
**Erika Vieira is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to www.amazon.com.
***Disclaimers: all opinions are my own, sponsors are acknowledged. Links in the description are typically affiliate links that let you help support the podcast at no extra cost.
