Site icon Erika Vieira

10 Hard Truths About Why Your YouTube Channel Isn’t Growing

Sarah

10 Hard Truths About Why Your YouTube Channel Isn’t Growing

After nearly a decade of producing YouTube channels and working with more than 2,000 women creators, I’ve learned that sometimes the most helpful YouTube growth advice isn’t the advice you necessarily want to hear.

I’ve watched incredibly talented women work hard on their channels and still struggle to get views, subscribers, or make money from YouTube. Usually, it’s not because they aren’t capable of succeeding. It’s because they’re spending their time and energy on the wrong things—or avoiding the changes that could actually move their channels forward.

So consider this a little YouTube tough love. If your channel isn’t growing the way you want it to, here are ten things I think you need to hear.

1. Your YouTube Thumbnails Might Be Too Complicated

I see creators spend hours designing beautiful thumbnails that simply don’t get clicks. They’re aesthetic, clever, creative…and confusing.

When in doubt, simplify.

YouTube isn’t an art gallery. Your thumbnail has an incredibly short amount of time to communicate why someone should stop scrolling and watch your video. Your viewer should be able to understand the basic promise of your video almost immediately.

I’ve worked with creators who saw dramatic improvements simply by making their thumbnails clearer. In one case, we switched to a thumbnail that prominently showed the creator’s transformation, and the video took off.

Creativity is wonderful, but clarity comes first. If viewers don’t understand your thumbnail, it doesn’t matter how beautiful it is.

2. You May Not Be Taking YouTube Seriously Enough

This one may sting, but YouTube is hard. Building a genuinely successful channel takes a tremendous amount of work, especially if you’re trying to turn it into a meaningful source of income.

I’ve worked with women who have full-time jobs, businesses, children, and incredibly busy lives who still find ways to make their channels a priority. They’re thinking about video ideas, studying thumbnails, analyzing what worked, and continually trying to improve.

I’m not advocating for permanent burnout or telling you to sacrifice your health for YouTube. But there may be seasons when building something meaningful requires delayed gratification. You might have to give up some free time or make choices other people aren’t willing to make.

There’s a difference between being interested in growing a YouTube channel and being committed to growing one. If you’re treating YouTube like a hobby but expecting business-level results, there’s a disconnect.

3. You’re Expecting YouTube Growth Too Quickly

I’ve been saying this for years: long form, long game.

YouTube is not a get-rich-quick platform, and expecting immediate results is one of the easiest ways to become discouraged and quit before your channel has a chance to gain momentum.

Think about growing a YouTube channel like growing a garden. You don’t plant seeds today and expect tomatoes tomorrow. You plant, water, adjust, learn what’s working, and continue tending to it until eventually you get the harvest.

Some videos will flop. Some strategies won’t work. You may spend months feeling like you’re putting in far more than you’re getting back.

The creators I’ve seen build sustainable channels understand that this is part of the process. They’re not expecting every video to explode. They’re willing to play the long game.

4. You May Be Spending Too Much Time on YouTube Shorts

I’ve analyzed the backend analytics of hundreds of channels, and for many of the creators I work with, Shorts simply don’t deliver the same business results as long-form YouTube videos.

Shorts can absolutely generate views and subscribers, but those numbers don’t always translate into meaningful revenue, long-form viewers, customers, or clients. Someone scrolling through Shorts is also in a very different consumption mode than someone who intentionally chooses to spend 15 or 20 minutes watching you solve a problem.

There are exceptions, and I’ve worked with creators for whom Shorts make sense. But I don’t want you creating them simply because you think you’re supposed to.

If you have limited time, ask yourself whether another Short is really the highest-value thing you could create—or whether that time would be better spent making an excellent long-form video.

5. Your Perfectionism Is Killing Your Momentum

Women love to tell me they’re perfectionists as though it’s evidence of how seriously they take their work. On YouTube, perfectionism can become one of the biggest things holding you back.

I’ve worked with creators who have gone months without uploading because every video needs to be perfect before they’re willing to publish it. They’ll film something, start editing, decide they don’t like it, and scrap the entire thing.

Meanwhile, the creators who improve are publishing.

Quality matters. I’m certainly not telling you to throw terrible videos onto your channel for the sake of consistency. But there is a point where striving for quality turns into fear and overthinking.

You get better at YouTube through repetition. Publish the video, study what happened, learn something, and make the next one better.

6. You’re Too Afraid of Being Negative

Some creators are so focused on being positive that their content loses contrast.

Videos about mistakes, warnings, what not to do, and problems to avoid can perform incredibly well because people naturally want to protect themselves from making the wrong decision.

That doesn’t mean becoming negative for the sake of clicks. It means being willing to tell your audience the truth.

If you’re a beauty creator and dislike a product, saying so can make your positive recommendations more credible. If you’re a fitness expert and see people repeatedly making the same mistake, explain why it’s a problem. If there’s something your audience needs to stop doing, tell them.

Helpful negativity isn’t about tearing people down. It’s about being honest enough to help them make better decisions.

7. Your Video Topics Aren’t Good Enough

You can have fantastic camera presence, professional editing, a beautiful set, and an amazing thumbnail, but none of those things can completely rescue a video topic nobody cares about.

Topic selection is one of the most important parts of YouTube strategy, and it’s something I spend a tremendous amount of time working on with my clients and Bootcampers.

A common mistake is making videos based entirely on what you want to talk about rather than what your audience wants to watch.

Before creating your next video, ask yourself what the viewer gets from it. What problem are you helping them solve? What question are you answering? What transformation, entertainment, inspiration, or outcome are you promising?

Great YouTube videos begin with great topics.

8. You Might Be in the Wrong YouTube Niche

Sometimes the problem isn’t your content. It’s the niche you’ve chosen to create content in.

I’ve seen creators struggle for years before realizing that another niche was a much better fit for their experience, personality, expertise, or competitive advantage.

One client was creating beauty content when I discovered that she was an exotic animal trainer in real life. Once she pivoted into content around exotic animals, her channel took off. Another creator moved from general beauty content for women over 50 into a much more specific fashion niche for plus-size, apple-shaped women over 50 and finally began finding her momentum.

You don’t get extra points for choosing the hardest possible path.

If your channel isn’t growing, it’s worth asking whether your current niche is really where you have the greatest opportunity to stand out.

9. You’re Ignoring Your Transformation

If you’ve experienced a meaningful transformation, you may be sitting on one of your best YouTube video ideas.

Before-and-afters are incredibly compelling because viewers can immediately understand the outcome. That transformation might involve weight loss, skincare, fitness, home organization, business growth, personal style, learning a skill, or almost anything else where there’s a visible or meaningful journey from point A to point B.

This is also why I’m constantly telling creators to document what they’re doing. Take the photos. Save the screenshots. Record the messy middle instead of waiting until you’ve reached the final result.

Your transformation doesn’t need to be perfect or dramatic to matter. Sometimes the most relatable journeys are the ones that feel attainable to the person watching.

10. Your Niche May Get Views Without Making Money

Finally, if your goal is to build a business through YouTube, you need to think about monetization when evaluating your niche.

Not every audience monetizes equally.

Some niches attract viewers who naturally buy products, invest in solutions, click affiliate links, hire service providers, or attract valuable brand partnerships. Others may generate plenty of views while offering fewer opportunities beyond AdSense.

That doesn’t mean you shouldn’t create content you love simply because it isn’t the most profitable niche on YouTube. But you do need to be clear about your goals.

If YouTube is a hobby, profitability doesn’t necessarily need to drive your decisions. If you’re treating your channel as a business and expecting it to produce a return on the enormous amount of time you’re investing, monetization needs to be part of your strategy from the beginning.

Stop Making Excuses and Start Making Changes

If your YouTube channel isn’t growing, I don’t want your immediate conclusion to be that you’re bad at YouTube.

I want you to look objectively at what’s happening.

Maybe your thumbnails need to become clearer. Maybe you need stronger video topics or a different niche. Maybe you’re spreading yourself too thin with Shorts, allowing perfectionism to destroy your consistency, or expecting results much faster than YouTube realistically delivers.

Successful creators aren’t necessarily the people who get everything right from day one. They’re the people willing to look honestly at what’s not working, make changes, and keep going.

You don’t need another year of spinning your wheels.

You need to identify what’s holding your channel back—and finally be willing to do something about it.

FREE RESOURCES

YOUTUBE COURSES AND COACHING

TRUSTED YOUTUBE TOOLS

RECOMMENDED YOUTUBE/PODCASTING EQUIPMENT:

*Links include affiliate links

**Erika Vieira is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to www.amazon.com.

***Disclaimers: all opinions are my own, sponsors are acknowledged. Links in the description are typically affiliate links that let you help support the podcast at no extra cost.

Podcast, YouTube Tips

Erika Vieira, Podcast, The YouTube Power Hour Podcast, youtube growth advice

Author: Erika Vieira

Marketing and sales expert Erika Vieira is the host and producer of the #1 influencer strategy podcast, The YouTube Power Hour. The podcast, with over 100 episodes and hundreds of thousands of downloads is dedicated to content creators who are looking to start, improve and grow their unique influence online. Erika works with influencers on personal branding, content improvement and defining a niche via customized strategy sessions, channel critiques and business support. She also loves makeup, beauty and her family and believes anyone who has the drive and passion can find success online. Feel free to send her a message here.

Exit mobile version